top of page

Work with SMEs

  1. Work Effectively with SME

  2. How Do You Measure Your Course Design Success?

  3. Working with SMEs Notebook

  4. Working with SMEs Planning Worksheet

1. Work Effectively with SME

Last updated on: Jun 11th, 2021 4:24PM by Jia Zhuang

The key to creating a productive working relationship with your SME is clear communication and expectation-setting.

Handshake

We are a team! 

At the first beginning of working with the SMEs, make it clear that as an ID, you don’t work for them, and they as SMEs, they don’t work for you, you two: ID and the SME, working as a team

 

Make sure the SMEs are your team members during the design process. Maintain open communication with them.  They are gonna bring great information about the topic as well as they are familiar with what must be in the course and what should be taken away from the eLearning experience.

 

Scheduling and Meetings

Set up deadlines, milestones and make a specific plan, so that SMEs can be aware of when each step of the process must be completed. Making sure they feel supported and always in the loop.

SMEs are experts in their field and are very busy people. Respect their time by keeping their interactions organized. Always show up to meetings prepared with discussion topics, and follow up with direct and clear requests and action items.

 

You can try to head this problem off at the start by being upfront about the time commitment before the SME agrees to take on the job. That may weed out particularly busy SMEs.

 

  • An estimate of how long it will take to complete

  • When it’s due

 

This type of schedule can help SMEs plan their time, and it also gives them some ammunition if they need to talk to their bosses about freeing up some time.

 

Once they sign on to the project, create a schedule with clear deadlines, and stick to them on your end to reinforce their importance. Share frequent project updates, and show them the work you’ve done on your end.

 

Show SMEs that you respect their time. Find out how your SMEs like to work. Do they prefer morning or afternoon meetings? Are certain days of the week or times better than others? Are several short phone calls better than one long meeting, or vice versa? Once you know your SMEs’ preferences, schedule meetings and deliverables accordingly. Begin and end meetings on time. And always be prepared so that meetings go quickly and smoothly.

 

Combatting an Expert Mind-set

Some SMEs have been experts for so long that they have trouble sharing their vast stores of knowledge in a way that you (and your target learners) can understand.

​

Ask SMEs to step inside the shoes of the learner. It’s important for SMEs to occasionally step inside the shoes of the learners and see things from their perspective. Encourage them to take a close look at all of the eLearning content and online resources as if they were actually taking the eLearning course.

  • Does the eLearning content give them the information they need in a timely manner?

  • Does it focus on the specific skills they require in their personal and professional lives?

  • Are there areas of the eLearning course that may be confusing or difficult to understand?

 

There are a few techniques you can use to bring them down to your level:

 

  • Explain it like I’m eight. Ask them to explain the subject the way they would to a small child. Then, use this simplified explanation, and build up to reach your desired level of expertise.

  • Ask for real-world examples. If your SME tends to get bogged down in theories, try to ground them by asking for specific examples and scenarios.

  • Provoke a reaction. If you still can’t get your SME to come down to your level, you can give this tactic a try. Explain a concept back to them badly, and let them correct you. Often, this change in approach can help them focus and explain concepts more clearly.

 

Prevent cognitive overload

Remind SMEs that learners do not need to become them. They don’t have a great deal of time to engage in the eLearning experience, which means we need to focus on what’s really important. And they need to bear in mind that learners simply need to remember the key takeaways and achieve their goals. Pick out/Prioritize what's Must know, and what's good to know. Leave the 'good to know' for Resources. 

 

Ask questions like:

  • How does this tie to our learning outcome?

  • What happens if the student doesn’t know this piece of information?

  • What do learners need to be able to do when this course is over? Can they do that without knowing this?

 

Last-minute unnecessary change? 

If you run into issues in spite of your careful prep work, your best course of action is to appeal to the SMEs ego. Make them feel heard. If they send you extra work, read it thoroughly and praise their efforts, even if you don’t plan to use it. Listen to their views and arguments even when you don’t agree. Then, remind them of the project’s goals and the importance of adhering to them.

2. How Do You Measure Your Course Design Success?

Three Spoons

Kirkpatrick Model

Reaction: (Were the participants pleased with the training?)

To what degree participants react favorably to the learning event (customer satisfaction) i.e, forms on which the student submits their feelings about the training.

 

Learning: (What did the participants learn from the training?)

To what degree participants acquire the intended knowledge, skills and attitudes based on their participation in the learning event  (Kirkpatrick recommends evaluating knowledge, skills and/or attitudes both before and after the training and use written tests to measure knowledge and attitudes and performance tests to measure skills.)

 

Behavior:  (Did the participants change their behavior based on what was learned?)

In order for change to occur, he goes on to say, four conditions are necessary:

  1. The person must have a desire to change

  2. The person must know what to do and how to do it

  3. The person must work in the right climate

  4. The person must be rewarded for changing (intrinsic and/or extrinsic)

 

Kirkpatrick recommends allowing sufficient time for the behavior change to take place before performing the evaluation.

He also recommends surveying/interviewing the trainees, their immediate supervisor, their subordinates, and others who often observe their behavior.

 

Results: (Did the change in behavior positively affect the organization?)

Kirkpatrick defines this level as identifying the final results that occurred because the student received the training. These results are things like: increased productivity, reduced errors, decreased costs etc. Ideally, these results will reflect the terminal objectives of the training.

Kirkpatrick recommends allowing for sufficient time for the results to be achieved.

3. Working with SMEs Notebook

Map

To facilitate the process and make sure that your Subject Matter Experts are on the same page with everyone on the team throughout the development experience, consider doing the following things:

 

  • Establish expectations and deadlines at the beginning.

  • Find ways to track progress. Set up schedule for regular meeting.

  • Have your questions ready before every meeting and make sure they are answered.

  • Provide online courses sample.

It is difficult to persuade anyone of anything without providing specific examples; you know that from your learners. Your Subject Matter Experts only know what they have experienced, so be prepared to show them the sample you made.

  • Ask for feedback regularly and often. Make sure your work always goes to the right direction.

4. Working with SMEs Planning Worksheet 

Designed Backyard

Click the documents below to take a look on my working with SMEs planning worksheet 2.0, which is a collaboration of various resources and my own experience summary. 

You are welcome to apply it to your own work!

​

Also, if you have any suggestions or better thoughts on specific steps, or you think something is lack in the worksheet, please let me know :) I'm always willing to learn more and make this worksheet better and more useful. (by jia, 10/21/2019 7:49pm)

​

Working with SMEs Planning Worksheet 2.0.pdf 

bottom of page